This week was Startup Cincy Week, an event hosted by one of Lyceum’s investors, Cintrifuse, where investors, founders, ecosystem partners, small business owners, and all sorts who are connected to the entrepreneurial ecosystem are connected in some way. I was there, shepherding a group of Miami students, helping make intros for them, connecting them with area resources, and otherwise helping them get as much as possible out of the event. I also spent a decent amount of time connecting with people from Cintrifuse, all of whom I love, and with other founders who have helped me along the way. I have never found a group of people so willing to go out of their way to help others as I have in the founder community, and specifically in the one here in Cincinnati (though I don’t have many points of reference). Lyceum, my prior startup, would have never succeeded without the local community supporting us (among many others who supported us). Throughout my life, I have been a part of a few different communities, mostly related to my professions and hobbies, but I’ve never found any of them meaningful until now. As an academic you build a bit of a community in your department and with the people that you see at conferences, but these always felt like relatively loose social ties to me. In board games, video games, and esports, there were always people to play with, to enjoy the shared hobby, but rarely people who took time out of their day to try to help you succeed.
My favorite American philosopher, John Dewey, has an essay titled, “The Lost Individual” which I’ve referenced before and will reference again and again before I eventually die. In it, he argues that people have lost their sense of meaning in the world and struggle to find a purpose that ties them together. He argues that historically meaning and purpose were derived from organized religion or from politics (interpreting that term loosely). You got your sense of what to do with your life from your religion or from your community and the way that you could serve their needs. If you didn’t know what to do, both groups would be perfectly willing to step in and tell you what to do. You were always free to make your own choices, but there was a backdrop for those choices that made them meaningful. Yet, as time marched forward, money eventually became the reason for everything. Your job isn’t to serve your community, it’s to make money. What you study isn’t for self-edification, it’s for money. Your value as a person is tied to your monetary net worth. You make decisions about career, children, and location based on money. The problem with money is that it has no inherent end. What is the goal of money? To get more money. It is insatiable in a way that religion and politics weren’t. Religion’s goal was some sort of glorification of god, whatever god that was. Politic’s goal was utopia on earth, whatever that vision of utopia happened to be. So each of those possessed specific goals that they were working towards that money lacks entirely.
What these ideas also did was create the possibility of community. You can accomplish very little on your own, so any politics, any desire for the common good, will require working with a bunch of people to achieve that. Every religion has similar requirements about doing good in the world and the best way to accomplish those goals is to work together. Both approaches get a bunch of people together, imbue them with a shared(ish) set of values and goals, and set them to work towards those values and goals. Community is a byproduct of that environment. Being in close proximity with others, depending on others and having them depend on you, knowing that others desire for your best just as you desire for theirs, and knowing that you’re all working towards the same goal creates a trust that wraps around every member engaged in that work.
Dewey laments the loss of community that came when politics and religion fell prey to rugged individualism. Politics and religion are now personal matters, things not to be discussed with others. Dewey’s argument isn’t that we need politics and religion to take center stage in our lives once again, but rather that we need something and he doesn’t seem to care much what that thing is. We need something that acts as a flagpole for us to gather under so that the work of community can once again begin.
I am not arguing that entrepreneurship is that thing, far from it. Merely that I can see a glimpse of what Dewey has in mind when I’m at Union Hall, the home of Cintrifuse and a few other local startups. Instead, what I want to argue is that Dewey is right, that we desperately need community. We are communal creatures at our core and we each possess a variety of strengths and weaknesses. Being able to cover for one another, to lend our strength to the group, feels great. Benefitting from the strength of others feels great. Strong communities support each other, they lean on each other, and they enrich the lives of those within them. The friend group that you’re very close to and that you wouldn’t trade for the world is just a very small community. We need larger communities, we need places where we feel connected to our neighbors and to those in the community that we haven’t yet met. I hate networking, I’m awful at it, and meeting a stranger is the last thing I want to do. But at Startup Cincy Week, I’m happy to chat with anyone because I know that as a member of the startup community we are going to share a bunch of stuff. We’re going to open doors for one another if we think it will help. We’re going to help each other brainstorm wacky ideas or point out problems in current ideas. We’re going to give each other advice with the hope that the other can succeed. We’re going to creatively problem solve together. I think what I hate about networking is the artificiality of it. In a community, you don’t need an artificial veneer, as you already have a shared table at which you sit. I’m not meeting someone thinking, “I hope I can get a job out of this”, I’m meeting them thinking “I want to hear about their cool stuff”.
Now, true community goes a lot further, I think. There’s some spatiality to it, there’s sacrifice, there’s value-oriented decision making as well as communal decision making. The startup community is by no means perfect, but it’s the closest I’ve experienced, and while I find the experience enjoyable, there’s something deeply troubling about it. Why is this not a common experience? Why is your HOA not a strong community? Why is your church not a strong community? Why is your book club, or your rec sports team, or your fantasy league, or your whatever not a strong community? For some of these, the answers are a bit easier. Your HOA isn’t a strong community because it’s ruled by control freaks with too much time on their hands. It lacks real community engagement. But your church, for instance, should be a strong community (even if you’re not religious). It’s ostensibly a locally oriented group of value-aligned people who are willing to give time and money to a mission. Yet, instead, it’s just a bunch of people who show up once a week (maybe) and say hello. Your book club is just the thing you do when you have time, your fantasy league exists for you to have some joy with your friends but nothing more. Hobbies are hard to build strong community around (though it can certainly happen). So, what are we left with if we think that Dewey is right? What possible things exist where our values align, where we are connected with the people physically around us, and where because of those connections, we want to help one another? I can think of a few possibilities, but they’re all quite weak. Parent groups for children in the same school could be a source of strong communities. The Green movement could be a source of a strong community. “Keep Austin Weird” (and that sentiment, transposed to anywhere) is funnily enough a possible source of strong community. Politics and religion are absolutely possible sources of strong community.
Broadly, I think it’s a deep shame that we’ve lost community. I think that politics and religion need to step back up and at least build back what was lost as best they’re able. This isn’t to say that everyone needs to get into politics or religion, but that when strong communities exist, it’s easier for more strong communities to form. I’ve even started working on an app for churches to help build strong community (if you are a church attender, reach out! Connect me with your church leadership). I’m reminded of a line from the Radiohead front-man, Thom Yorke that I saw in an interview years ago where he said something like, “I got into the music business thinking it was going to be a bunch of creative people working together and I was deeply disappointed to find out that it was a business.” Too many of our possible communities take that form. They could be strong communities, but we’ve turned them into commodities.
Writing time: 42 minutes with maybe 10 minutes spent chasing my dog in the backyard to get him to stop barking.
As a reminder, this essay follows all my rules here: https://showeressays.substack.com/about

